The Tag Hill Trophy was presented in 1953 by Mrs. Maytag McCahill Jr., a past President of WGAWP. It was to be retired by the player who won it three consecutive years. Up until 199x it was played as 36 hole stroke play on two different courses. From 1953 until 1962 the event was open to Class A players. Beginning in 1963 the event was open to qualified handicaps.
| Year | Sites | Champion | Winning Score | Runner Up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1953 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Maureen Riley | 162 O-87 P-75 | Joan Wassell |
| 1954 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Mrs. Thomas E. Nolan | 162 O-86 P-76 | Betty Abernethy & Jane Martin |
| 1955 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Phyllis Semple | 166 O-85 P-81 | Mrs. Thomas Nolan |
| 1956 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Phyllis Semple | 165 O-84 P-81 | Maureen Riley |
| 1957 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Jane Martin | 161 O-86 P-75 | Phyllis Semple & Mrs. John Haskell |
| 1958 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Diana Hoke | 165 O-83 P-82 | Jane Martin |
| 1959 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Diana Hoke | 165 O-85 P-80 | Phyllis Semple |
| 1960 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Betty Abernethy | 166 O-86 P-80 | Mrs. John H. Haskell |
| 1961 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Mary Ann Sherry | 159 O-81 P-78 | Ann White |
| 1962 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Phyllis Semple | 166 O-87 P-79 | |
| 1963 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Suzy Williams (Broadhurst) | 164 O-82 P-82 | Phyllis Semple |
| 1964 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Phyllis Semple | 161 O-81 P-81 | Suzy Williams (Broadhurst) |
| 1965 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Jane Martin | 163 O-87 P-76 | Mrs. W. H. Bierman Jr. |
| 1966 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Jane Martin | 162 O-81 P-81 | Phyllis Semple |
| 1967 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Phyllis Semple | 154 O-81 P-73 | |
| 1968 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Kathleen Westlund | 168 O-86 P-82 | Marcia Jones |
| 1969 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Carol Semple (Thompson) | 157 O-85 P-72 | Phyllis Semple |
| 1970 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Phyllis Semple | Suzy Broadhurst | |
| 1971 | Pgh Field Club & Longue Vue | Carol Semple (Thompson) | ||
| 1972 | Oakmont & Pgh Field Club | Suzy Williams Broadhurst | Iris Teplitz | |
| 1973 | Pgh Field Club & Oakmont | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1974 | Oakmont & Allegheny | Suzy Williams Broadhurst | Mrs. R. F. Moreland | |
| 1975 | Allegheny & Sewickley Heights | Suzy Williams Broadhurst | Fran Capian | |
| 1976 | Allegheny & Sewickley Heights | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1977 | Chartiers & South Hills | Nancy Rubin | ||
| 1978 | Shannopin & St. Clair | Nancy Rubin | Nancy Tomich | |
| 1979 | Fox Chapel & Pgh Field Club | Linda Hogue | ||
| 1980 | Allegheny & Longue Vue | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1981 | Pgh Field Club & Butler | Ericha Benshoff | ||
| 1982 | Allegheny & Butler | Michele Berteotti | ||
| 1983 | Churchill & Green Oaks | Fran Caplan | ||
| 1984 | Allegheny & Butler | Michele Berteotti | ||
| 1985 | Allegheny & Longue Vue | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1986 | Alcoma & Allegheny | Carol Semple Thompson | ||
| 1987 | Chartiers & Butler | Laurie Swanson | ||
| 1988 | Allegheny & Edgewood | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1989 | Latrobe & Chartiers | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1990 | Chartiers & Butler | Mrs. Thomas Manderino | ||
| 1991 | St. Clair & Nemacolin | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1992 | Montour & Allegheny | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1993 | Chartiers & Hill Crest | Liz Collins | ||
| 1994 | Rolling Hills & Pleasant Valley | Courtney Myhrum | ||
| 1995 | Youghiogheny & Sunnehanna | Judy Oliver | ||
| 1996 | Diamond Run & Shannopin | Betsy Manderino | ||
| 1997 | Indiana & HillCrest | Maureen Paladino | ||
| 1998 | Youghiogheny & Diamond Run | Betsy Manderino | ||
| 1999 | Treesdale & Ligonier | Wendy Knafel |
